Comparing 5/1 ARM and Fixed-Rate Mortgage

What you need to know about 5-1 adjustable rate mortgages

Borrowers have a wide range of options when selecting a mortgage. The 5/1 ARM is one mortgage product that is gaining popularity (adjustable rate mortgage). This article will define a 5/1 ARM, discuss its benefits and drawbacks, and examine how it stacks up against other mortgage products.

What is a 5/1 ARM?

A 5/1 ARM has a fixed interest rate for the first five years of the loan term. After this initial period, interest rates may be adjusted annually depending on market conditions. A "5" indicates the number of years the interest rate will remain fixed, while a "1" indicates the frequency of interest rate adjustments (once per year).

Fixed-Rate Mortgage versus ARM

A mortgage is a loan that can be used to purchase or refinance a home. A fixed-rate mortgage has an interest rate that does not change throughout the loan term. This means that the monthly payment (principal and interest) on the loan will remain the same for its whole duration.

On the other hand, an ARM may have a lower initial interest rate, but it can fluctuate over time based on changes in market conditions.

For example, a 5/1 ARM may have an initial interest rate of 3%, which will remain fixed for the first five years of the loan term but may increase after that. The benefit of an ARM is that it can provide more flexibility and allows one to take advantage of changing market conditions.

However, if rates suddenly increase, so will one's monthly payments and, ultimately, their total cost of borrowing. Fixed-rate and ARM mortgages can be beneficial depending on one's current financial situation and future goals.

Pros of a 5/1 ARM

One of a 5/1 ARM's key benefits is that, for the first five years, the interest rate is often lower than that of a fixed-rate mortgage. Borrowers may save a lot of money on their monthly mortgage payments as a consequence of this.

Furthermore, because the interest rate is subject to yearly change, borrowers may profit if rates decline over time.

A 5/1 ARM may also benefit borrowers by allowing them greater flexibility with their mortgage payments. For instance, a borrower could afford a more outstanding monthly mortgage payment if their salary grows considerably after the first five years.

Cons of a 5/1 ARM

The interest rate of a 5/1 ARM may dramatically rise beyond the first five-year term, which is its biggest drawback. Borrowers may see larger monthly mortgage payments, which may make it more challenging for them to purchase their house.

Furthermore, if interest rates increase, borrowers can pay more in interest through than they would with a fixed-rate mortgage. Another possible negative of a 5/1 ARM is that it might be difficult for borrowers to forecast their future monthly mortgage payments. Because of this, it could be more difficult for borrowers to stick to a budget and develop financial plans.

Comparing 5/1 ARMs to Other Mortgage Options

When evaluating 5/1 ARMs versus other mortgage options, it is important to weigh their strengths and weaknesses. For instance, a fixed-rate mortgage may be well suited for those who desire the assurance of knowing exactly what their monthly payments are for the duration of the loan. However, a 5/1 ARM may offer more attractive interest rates and greater price flexibility, making it an attractive choice for borrowers who accept more risk.

Ultimately, the best mortgage choice depends on each borrower's circumstances and financial goals. By understanding the pros and cons of a 5/1 ARM, borrowers can decide whether this type of mortgage is right for them.

When evaluating a 5/1 ARM, it's essential to consider the loan's caps and margins. Caps limit how much the interest rate can increase or decrease during the loan term. At the same time, margins are the added percentage over the index rate (such as the LIBOR or the Treasury rate) that the lender uses to set the adjustable rate. A loan with lower caps and margins can provide more predictability and stability for the borrower but may also have a higher initial interest rate.

A 5/1 ARM may be a better choice for everyone, however. A fixed-rate mortgage may be better for borrowers who intend to stay in their home for an extended period or are uncomfortable with the risk of changing interest rates.

How Caps and Margins Affect the Predictability and Stability of a 5/1 ARM

Caps and margins are essential factors to consider when evaluating a 5/1 ARM. During an adjustable-rate period, caps refer to the maximum amount by which the interest rate may increase or decrease, while margins refer to the amount the lender adds to the index rate to determine the adjustable rate. As a result of caps and margins, a 5/1 ARM can be predictable and stable.

A 5/1 ARM, for instance, would have a maximum interest rate of 7.5% (5% index rate plus 2.5% margin plus 2% limit) and a 2% ceiling on interest rate increases. For the borrower, knowing that their interest rate won't rise over this point might provide a feeling of certainty and stability.

On the other hand, a 5/1 ARM with a 5% cap and a 3% margin would have a maximum interest rate of 12% (5% index rate + 3% margin + 5% cap). This can be less predictable and stable for the borrower, as their interest rate could increase significantly during the adjustable rate period.

How a Prepayment Penalty Can Affect a 5/1 ARM

A prepayment penalty is another crucial factor when evaluating a 5/1 ARM. If borrowers pay off their loan early, whether they sell the property or refinance, they may be charged a prepayment penalty. Prepayment penalties may be substantial on some 5/1 ARMs, so it's important to carefully review the loan terms and determine if you are comfortable with these features.

The possible effect of prepayment penalties must be considered while evaluating a 5/1 ARM. For example, if a borrower chooses to pay off a 5/1 ARM early with a 2% prepayment penalty, there may be a significant extra expense. On the other hand, a 5/1 ARM without a prepayment penalty would let the borrower pay off the loan early without accruing any additional costs, which may provide more flexibility and financial freedom.

How the Length of the Loan Term Affects a 5/1 ARM

The loan term is another consideration. A 5/1 ARM typically has a loan term of 30 years, which is the standard for most mortgages. However, some lenders may offer a shorter or shorter loan term. In contrast, if the loan term is faster, the monthly payments will be higher, but the borrower will pay less interest over the loan's lifecycle. On the other hand, a longer loan term means lower monthly payments but is more reasonable.

You must think about your financial objectives and what is most practical while selecting a 5/1 ARM. If your income is reliable and you can make more outstanding monthly payments, a shorter loan term could be the preferable choice. A more extended loan period could be more suitable if you have a more unpredictable income and require lower monthly payments.

How Your Creditworthiness Affects a 5/1 ARM

Finally, while assessing a 5/1 ARM, it's critical to consider your creditworthiness. Your credit history and score heavily influence the interest rate and conditions of the loan. Borrowers with higher credit scores and more extended credit histories often get better loan conditions and cheaper interest rates. Borrowers may be liable to higher interest rates and less favorable loan conditions if their credit score is low and they have a bad credit history.

Choosing the Right Lender for a 5/1 ARM

When considering a 5/1 ARM, choosing a reputable lender that offers competitive rates and terms is essential. To help you find the right lender, here are a few tips:

Compare rates and terms. Shop around and compare the rates and terms offered by different lenders. Compare the caps, margins, prepayment penalties, and the lender's fees and closing costs.

Check the lender's reputation. Research the lender's reputation and customer reviews to ensure they have a history of providing exemplary service and have positive feedback from previous customers.

Consider the lender's customer service. Ensure the lender has a dedicated team of loan officers who can guide you through the process.
Look for a lender with a low rate of defaults and foreclosures. This can be a good indicator of a lender's risk management and overall stability.

Following these tips and carefully evaluating the loan terms and lender's reputation, you can make an informed decision aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance.


For many borrowers, a 5/1 ARM may be a great choice, but it's essential to thoroughly consider the terms and circumstances and compare them to other loan alternatives. Borrowers can make an informed choice that is in line with their financial objectives and risk tolerance by being aware of the critical variables that influence a 5/1 ARM, such as caps, margins, prepayment penalties, loan term, creditworthiness, lender reputation, customer service, fees, and closing costs.

In addition, choosing the right lender and evaluating their reputation, customer service, and risk management can also be crucial factors in ensuring a successful and smooth mortgage experience. With the correct information and guidance, a 5/1 ARM can be a powerful tool to achieve your homeownership goals.

SOURCE:  Consumer Handbook on Adjustable-rate Mortgages

Recommended Reading

  1.  Compare Current Mortgage Rates Today for Conventional Loans 
  2.  Conforming loan limit: what you need to know 
  3.  Conventional 97 Loan Pros and Cons